logologo

Menu

  • Home
  • Tools for my location
  • Downloaded tools
logologo
  • Credits
  • Whistleblowing
  • initiative for coffee&climate
  • Privacy Policy
  • Imprint
Back
  1. Trainer Section
  2. 5 step approach
  3. Step 2
D

Collect scientific information

  • #STEP-2.DStart
  • Theory
  • Past and present climate
  • Future climate projections: Dealing with uncertainties
  • A lack of scientific data
  • Practical Guidance
  • Objectives, Expected outputs, Required time

Abstract

Finding, interpreting and making practical use of available scientific information on climate change is not easy – especially if you are dealing with a crop like coffee.

Method

Desk study: assessment of climate studies and future climate models (by experts)

Expected Results

Summary of information about current and future climate change, climate hazards and impacts

Theory

Past and present climate

An important step in gathering scientific information is to access meteorological data and, if possible, to approach any local meteorological institutes. Local research institutions or coffee umbrella organizations may also have relevant data.

Meteorological data are often presented as a set of averages, but for the purposes of farming, it is actually more important to have the extreme values (e.g. maximum and minimum temperatures). That said, some countries have daily records available, which allows for more analyses of raw data by those with corresponding skills and experience. For example, by interpreting meteorological information and putting it into a specific format, such as climate maps or climate models, such information can easily be presented to outside audiences (see “Learning from experience: Climate maps for stakeholder use” on page 44).

It is important to look for extreme temperature values and determine if they are becoming either more extreme or more frequent. In addition, make sure to look at the timing and intensity of rainfall. Although there may be no indication of changes in annual rainfall, there could be signs of more intermittent rainfall or changes in the onset or end of the rainy season. Where possible, seek the assistance of a meteorologist.

Keep in mind that other organizations may have already conducted similar research. Therefore, it is also helpful to consult government officials and research organizations or NGOs in your region.

Important Note

Information on current changes in climate conditions, as well as extremes that have occurred over the past decades in your area, is based on scientific sources and the perceptions and observations of farmers and stakeholders. Contrastingly, any predictions of future climate change are based only on scientific projections.

It is important to keep in mind that scientific data is often available only for larger scales, but farmers and stakeholders allow you to validate these larger trends and to understand the perceptions of how the climate is changing locally.

Learning from experience
an aerial view of a woman digging in a banana plantation .

Difficulties in scientific data analysis

Scientific data can include past meteorological records, climate models for the region or specific studies. However, many people encounter difficulties when analyzing this information. In some places, the meteorological record is incomplete or inaccurate. Even when data are available, this information is rarely presented in a form that is easy to understand.

Meteorological data may be available only as monthly maximums and minimums of temperature and rainfall. Specific data that are of interest to coffee, e.g. timing of the first rains, exact length of the dry season or extremes of temperatures, may often not be available. This creates a tendency to rely on projections in climate models, but it is important to remember that these present a range of future possibilities rather than real predictions.

It should also be noted that uncertainty is inherent to climate projections; no one knows for sure which of these future possibilities (if any) will be correct. However, attempts have been made to determine not only possibilities, but also probabilities. The latter are often subjective, e.g. an estimate based on the available information and evidence. For example, scientists may weigh future projections according to how well they represent the past climate. When using projections, you must always remember that these are not rigid predictions on which to base precise decisions, but rather a means of understanding the range of impacts that are possible in a given region.

Future climate projections: Dealing with uncertainties

There is an increasing number of climate models that project changes in temperature and precipitation for the coming years – as far into the future as 2100. These models can give you a rough idea of future climate change, but are still very uncertain in terms of future levels of greenhouse gas emissions (which will influence the scale and speed of changes projected), interpretations of atmospheric and earth systems (which can also lead to different projections), and interpretations of future risks and hazards.

If you need to choose from a number of projections on which to base your work, it is important to understand how they were created and to determine if they feature a range of models and scenarios. Where possible, seek expert advice when choosing which projections you will use – for example, from the meteorological office. Different models tend to agree on some changes more than others. For example, virtually all models predict an increase in temperature, but they often have conflicting predictions for the rate of this increase. There are also generally great differences in predictions of rainfall. In order to show these differences and uncertainties, models will often present a range of possible future outcomes. For example, a projected 3°C temperature increase by 2050 may come with an uncertainty range of 1.5°C to 5°C; average rainfall projections for a region may be negative, but the uncertainty range can be from 20-50%.

Climate projections are often only available at the regional or national level, and may not provide the specific detail required at the local level. However, if used correctly, they can still be a valuable source of information for future trends in a given area. At the very least, they can be used to visualize climate change and can thus support in creating awareness among stakeholders.

A lack of scientific data

Unfortunately, in many coffee-producing countries, good meteorological data can be scarce and research stations few; historical data can often be incomplete – especially at the local level. If that is the case, consult local historians, anthropologists and other experts, either professional or amateur, in addition to consulting the Internet.

  • The historical record: Coffee production often has a long and rich history. Reports from research stations and commodity boards may offer useful information, and careful analysis of this material can often reveal evidence about past climatic events, as well as changes in land use and production levels. Other official bodies, including government departments for rural affairs or civil work, as well as NGOs, may also have useful archives.
  • Private data: Some larger coffee plantations may have records that go back for decades, and some may even have meteorological data.
  • Public data: Newspaper archives can be a rich source of information about past extreme weather events and may even include specific meteorological information.

All of the sources above are likely to provide some useful data, which can together provide a comprehensive assessment of past climate change. However, data will take time and resources to collect. If scientific information is not available and further studies cannot be conducted, be sure to thoroughly analyze the information that is collected from farmers and stakeholders.

Learning from experience
a view of a lush green valley with mountains in the background and clouds in the sky .

Climate maps for stakeholder use

For the c&c pilot in Brazil, there was a lack of adequate consolidated climatic information and difficulties in assessing meteorological data. Therefore, c&c commissioned Dr. Ramiro Ruiz from the University of Belo Horizonte, Brazil to format the meteorological information for Minas Gerais into climate maps that can be used by coffee stakeholders. These climate maps show detailed information of recent climate change (e.g. decrease of rainfall in the north-east of Minas Gerais, Brazil) and, through modeling, can identify future trends.

.

Figure 12: Comparison of rainfall amount in Minas Gerais (Brazil)
a map showing the amount of rainfall from january to march 1961-1980 and january to march 1981-2011 .
Learning from experience
a woman is kneeling in a field looking at a cell phone .
Figure 13: Mean temperature increase (°C) per decade for 12 Central Highlands locations
a graph showing mean temperature increase per decade for 12 central highlands locations

Presenting temperature increase for stakeholders

In Step 1, existing information about climate change in Vietnam was reviewed. However, this only provided a very general view of climate change. There was a need to further examine the meteorological records to determine which climate aspects relevant to coffee production were changing. A study was commissioned with the University of Hanoi that compiled data on all individual weather stations in the Central Highlands.

Results showed changes in rainfall distribution over the past 40 years, as well as much higher rates of temperature increase than national averages. The figure below highlights that mean decade temperatures are increasing very rapidly, especially in the dry season, which has implications for coffee production and water consumption. (The same methodology was applied as in the case of the climate maps for Minas Gerais, Brazil, however, due to a much lower number of meteorological stations in Vietnam a different format was used for presenting results.)

.

Practical Guidance

Objectives

  • To know and understand how the climate will change in a region and how this will impact the population and agricultural production.
  • To collect information on current and projected climate change, including changes in temperature, rainfall, extreme weather events and any other important phenomena based on scientific sources online.
  • To summarize, analyze and interpret this scientific information.

Expected outputs

  • A list of available documents, studies and reports.
  • A summary of available information on climate change in a specific country and coffee production region, and possible impacts on the coffee production.

Required time

One to two weeks, depending on the availability of data and the existing knowledge of the researcher.

Figure 37: Rainfall amount over the last 30 years in Mbeya, Tanzania
a graph showing mbeya total rainfall from 1980 to 2015

Procedure

  • Review and evaluate existing studies and predictions by the IPCC for the specific region (see online information below).
  • Find out if there are existing predictions of climate change in the region from sources such as the Ministry of Environment, the meteorological service, scientific institutes or international development organizations.
  • Review the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) for your specific country. The National Communications are the official reports from member countries of the UNFCCC and contain detailed information on the expected impacts of climate change for specific countries.
  • Organize scientific information in terms of current and future climate hazards, current and expected impacts (e.g. labeled as ‘Temperatures’, ‘Rainfall’ and ‘Extreme weather events and other phenomena’), as well as possible options for adaptation.
  • If possible, create conclusions on what this information means for your specific region (see Figure 43).
  • It is recommended to seek the help of a climate change expert in analyzing information (e.g. for constructing climate maps).
Important Note

Collecting, interpreting and making practical use of scientific information on climate change is not easy – especially when determining how climate change may affect a crop like coffee in a specific area.

Sources of information

Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change reports: The IPCC prepares comprehensive Assessment Reports about knowledge on climate change, its causes, potential impacts and response options. www.ipcc.ch/reports

United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) National Communications: These documents communicate the results of national assessments of greenhouse gas emissions, as well as information on vulnerability, impacts and adaptation. https://unfccc.int/non-annex-I-NCs

The World Bank Climate Change Knowledge Portal: This platform provides an online tool for access to comprehensive global, regional and country data related to historical, current and future climate impact and vulnerability. https://climateknowledgeportal.worldbank.org/

Climate Wizard provides climate change information and visualizes the impacts anywhere on earth. https://ccafs.cgiar.org/index.php/resources/tools/climate-wizard

The Adaptation Learning Mechanism provides country summaries on observed and projected climate change and impacts. https://ndcpartnership.org/knowledge-portal/climate-toolbox/adaptation-learning-mechanism-alm

Public data: Newspaper archives can be a rich source of information about previous extreme climatic events and may include specific meteorological information.

There are many other sources of information, often region- or country-specific, which are not listed here. Make sure to search the Internet thoroughly and to consult local experts.

All the above sources are likely to provide useful data and a comprehensive assessment of past climate change. If scientific information is not available and further studies cannot be conducted, it is recommended to thoroughly analyze information provided by farmers and stakeholders and work primarily with these results.